Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex, has been a polarizing figure for several years. The criticism and animosity directed at her from some members of the public, the media, and certain segments of society can be attributed to a variety of factors, including her personal choices, her departure from royal duties, and her relationship with the British royal family. Below are some of the key reasons behind the backlash and criticism:
1. Perceived Disruption of Royal Tradition
Meghan’s decision to marry Prince Harry, a member of the British royal family, drew significant attention. As an American actress with no aristocratic background, some saw her as an outsider who didn’t fit into the traditional royal mold. Her modern, independent persona clashed with the more conservative, restrained nature of the royal family. The couple’s decision to step back from their royal duties in 2020 and seek financial independence was seen by some as a break from tradition and disrespectful to the monarchy.
- Departure from Royal Duties: Their decision to step away from royal roles (the so-called “Megxit”) led to a massive public outcry. Many viewed it as a betrayal of royal duties, especially because Prince Harry, as a senior royal, was expected to fulfill certain public roles. The couple’s desire for privacy and financial independence was interpreted by some as hypocrisy, especially when they later entered lucrative deals with companies like Netflix and Spotify.
2. Media Criticism and “Victimization”
Meghan and Harry’s relationship with the media has been a significant source of tension. Meghan has often spoken about her struggles with negative press coverage, particularly regarding racist and sexist treatment. However, some critics feel that Meghan and Harry have exaggerated or manipulated their victimhood narrative.
- Claims of Racism: Meghan publicly stated that she faced racism within the royal family and from the British media. These claims were central to the couple’s infamous 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey. While many supported Meghan’s statements, others viewed the claims as self-serving or as an attempt to deflect from personal responsibility for their actions.
- Media War: Meghan and Harry’s ongoing legal battles against the British tabloids, including suing the Mail on Sunday, added fuel to the fire. Some people feel that by consistently battling the press, they create a “them vs. us” situation, making it harder for the public to sympathize with their grievances.
3. Privileged Life vs. Advocacy
Meghan Markle has been criticized for her advocacy for social causes, which some feel is out of touch with her privileged status. Critics have accused her of hypocrisy for promoting causes like climate change while traveling in private jets, or for advocating for social justice while living in a mansion in California.
- Hypocrisy: Meghan and Harry’s lifestyle choices, such as their move to a lavish estate in Montecito after stepping back from royal duties, have been criticized for not matching the image of the humble, socially conscious figures they present. The public often finds it hard to reconcile their calls for privacy and their lucrative media deals, which some believe contradict the values they profess.
4. Royal Family Dynamics
Meghan’s relationship with the royal family, particularly with Prince William and Kate Middleton, has been the subject of much speculation. She and Harry have spoken publicly about their strained relationship with certain family members. This has drawn criticism from royal supporters who view the royal family as an institution that should maintain unity and dignity.
- Tensions with the Royal Family: The Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s public airing of their grievances with the royal family in the Oprah interview, including accusations of lack of support and concerns about their son’s skin color, left many feeling uncomfortable and divided. Some felt that the couple’s actions undermined the royal family, which is expected to remain above petty drama.
5. Cultural and Racial Issues
Meghan, being biracial, has discussed how racism played a role in her treatment both by the media and within the royal family. However, her critics often dismiss her claims, suggesting that race is being used as an excuse for her behavior or that she is playing the “race card” to gain sympathy. This has polarized public opinion, especially in a country like the UK, where issues of race and class are deeply rooted and sensitive.
6. Public Perception of Her Personality
Meghan Markle’s personality and public demeanor also play a role in her criticism. Some see her as self-absorbed or overly concerned with her image, particularly in interviews or public appearances. Her outspokenness and willingness to criticize institutions like the monarchy and the media may also be seen by some as a reflection of entitlement or arrogance.
- Perception of “Victimhood”: Some critics view Meghan’s public statements about her struggles as an attempt to present herself as a victim, which they feel undermines her credibility. The perception that she often plays the victim card, particularly when discussing her experiences with the royal family and the media, has turned some people against her.
7. Disconnection from the Public
Meghan and Harry’s decision to take part in various high-profile media deals, such as their multi-million-dollar contracts with streaming services, has led many to view them as out of touch with ordinary people. Their actions have sometimes been seen as self-serving, especially in light of their desire for privacy while simultaneously profiting from media exposure.
- “Holier-than-thou” Image: Meghan’s advocacy for mental health, women’s rights, and environmental issues is commendable, but some critics feel that her approach has come across as self-congratulatory or as though she believes she is morally superior to others, which turns some people off.
8. Online Hate and “Cancel Culture”
Meghan Markle has been a frequent target of online harassment, and some of the negative opinions about her can be attributed to the rise of “cancel culture.” Social media has amplified these sentiments, and Meghan is often the subject of memes, hashtags, and vitriol. This type of widespread online hate can shape public perception and contribute to the idea that “everyone” dislikes her, even if this is not entirely accurate.
Conclusion
The reasons behind Meghan Markle’s polarizing reputation are multifaceted and reflect a combination of her personal actions, her relationship with the royal family, her approach to public life, and the larger socio-political context. While Meghan has a significant number of supporters who sympathize with her struggles, advocate for her causes, and appreciate her breaking royal norms, there is also a large group of detractors who find her actions controversial, self-serving, or hypocritical. Public opinion remains divided, and her journey has sparked ongoing debates about race, class, privilege, and the role of modern celebrities.
It’s important to note that the opinions expressed about Meghan are not universally shared. Some people admire her courage, activism, and ability to carve out her own path, while others are critical for a variety of reasons. Ultimately, the “hate” directed at her is the result of a complex mix of factors, and public opinion about her continues to evolve.